Blogging Out Loud

Connecting You with the Latest Marketing Tips and Trends.

What Would a Marketer of the Year Say?

5 Questions For Bill Weintraub — industry veteran and visionary.

For Bill Weintraub, the strategy behind successful marketing has not changed much over time: know your product, know your audience and communicate effectively.

Our industry is teeming with great leaders and visionaries, people from whom we all have much to learn. Bill Weintraub is one such person. After all, he’s been BrandWeek magazine’s Marketer of the Year and was named Outstanding Chief Marketing Executive by Frohlinger’s Marketing Report. He’s served as Chief Marketing Officer at Tropicana and Coors Brewing, and prior to that, he managed brands for the Kellogg Company, where his leadership fostered new success for Kellogg brands and marketers alike, when he championed efforts to allow food products to make health claims and thus ushered in a new era in food marketing. Before that, he managed iconic brands such as Scope, Prell, Sure and Crest for Procter & Gamble. Bill is currently a faculty member at the University of Colorado and an executive mentor to M.B.A. students at the University of Denver. We caught up with Bill last week and — not surprisingly — he had plenty of knowledge to share from his own storied and successful career in marketing and how it relates to current trends in marketing and popular culture.

Blogging Out Loud: You’ve seen a lot of changes over the years. How do you identify passing fads from lasting trends? Is there a secret?

Bill Weintraub: I really don’t think the underlying principles of communication and persuasion have changed that much since the times of Aristotle. Too many people — in the media, especially — get hung up on fads. Fads, or fashions, they come and go. For me, it’s the underlying principles of communications and strategy that matter:

— Understanding your product and/or service
— Identifying the consumer group for which its benefits are important
— Utilizing communication to demonstrate that

Some people don’t understand these basic principles. They get hung up on the fad.

BOL: What are your go-to resources — whether they are on the streets, in print or online — for keeping up on trends?

BW: I’m a big believer in magazines, whether I’m reading them on my iPad or physically. I read AdAge, Adweek, Business Week and Fortune. But I’m also a big believer of keeping track of pop culture, by reading magazines like People and US Weekly. That’s what people are interested in, so for me, it’s more important to keep in touch with pop culture.

BOL: When teaching, how do you balance new platforms, such as social media, against tried and true tricks of the trade?

BW: I don’t think social media — or, any one medium — is that important. Social media may work for some brands, and it may not for others. Television is still the dominant medium of our time — it accounts for two-thirds of spending among major advertisers — and the reason why is you can tell a story and dramatize something on television that you can’t in other mediums. That’s not to say social media, outdoor media, radio, and newspapers don’t have a place.

The key point is what advertising causes you — as a consumer — to switch to another brand from your current brand. That’s what effective marketing is about; it’s no more difficult than that. What causes brand switching? Does that advertising give the consumer some inclination to say, “You know what, I’m going to switch…” Does it provide some motivation? It’s mundane stuff. You have to understand pop culture, and a little bit of psychology. Think out how real people act. That’s how people make decisions.

BOL: What social media platform do you find most exciting and why?

BW: I go on Facebook and I follow some Twitter [feeds], but I don’t think it’s that important. If there’s a strategy that communicates some advantage to some group of consumers for whom that message resonates — that’s what important. Being cool isn’t that important. Look at what Pepsi did last year when they tried to be “cool” and shifted monies from television to social media; they really screwed up…

BOL: What marketing and promotional campaigns/tools are you excited about now?

BW: I don’t consider myself a dilettante of what’s good. If it builds business, it’s good. For you or I to judge advertising before we know the results, it’s very risky. There’s no correlation between what consumers like and effective advertising. It might be a little different in terms of promotions because you have the element of price, particularly in this economy, when people are more concerned about price. I think PR works the same way. In a sense, social media can be a vehicle for good PR, as long as there’s a strategy.

“5 Questions For” is a new and occasional feature in which Blogging Out Loud interviews influential industry leaders on current and future marketing trends.

Brought to you by Vertical Marketing Network, a Leading Integrated Marketing Agency.
Photo credit: Stock photo

About JJ Nelson

Freelance blogger for Vertical Marketing Network; food writer; bartender.

6 comments on “What Would a Marketer of the Year Say?

  1. joannemhilton
    December 1, 2011

    It was interesting to read that although Bill follows the Social Media Fad, he still really feels it comes down to the basics. I have to say that what affects my brand switching is magazines and TV … most effective are coupons which gives me the opportunity to try something new at a savings. Great article!


  2. Francis
    December 1, 2011

    Bill makes a great point when he proclaims that it’s difficult to judge advertising before knowing the results of its effectiveness. I’ve often been caught initially shaking my head at an ” irreverent” campaign only to have it become a nationwide hit. “Wasssssssaaaaappp, anyone?”


  3. Diane
    November 30, 2011

    Wow – this is really a different take on social media! Even though advertising dollars are being spent on television – with the always available mute button – I wonder how much impact these stores are having.


  4. Dan Fox
    November 30, 2011

    Bill Weintraub was my client for all his 10 years at Coors. As this “5 Questions” article illustrates, he is a man of thoughtful, painstakingly validated, and clearly articulated principles when it comes to marketing. Nearly every big, noisy mistake we’ve seen in marketing over the years would have never happened had those making the decisions ever studied under Bill.


    • JJ Nelson
      December 9, 2011

      Thanks for the comment, Dan. Bill certainly has a lot of knowledge to share.


  5. Alice
    November 30, 2011

    Bill’s a great example to stick to basic staples in the industry. I appreciated his honestly on how he felt about social media. Even though it is the up and coming trend to attract consumers, I personally respond mostly to TV and magazine ads more. Although I’m probably on social media far more often than through the other medias, I dont find the tactics that luring for me.


Share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email.


Follow us!

%d bloggers like this: